7 Best Popover Pans – Baking Without Frustration

  • Last updatedLast updated: Jul 17, 2020
View Article Statistics

If you love cooking, you are sure to be one of those people who love to explore new recipes and ideas. Popovers are one of those versatile baking items that can be made both in sweet and savoury versions and everyone likes them because they are really airy, tasty and pretty at the same time. If you want to create your own popovers at home, you will need some special equipment. The best popover pans are nonstick and they look different than regular muffin pans, because they are specially designed for this particular type of baking goods.

We reviewed 28 of the best popover pans currently available in the market and concluded that the Silicone Texas Muffin Pans and Cupcake Maker is the best money can buy. We featured this pan as our editor’s choice because it is made from commercial grade silicone and is very simple to use and easy to clean, which is very important with these types of pans. We also included six other models in our reviews so you can easily find one that best suits your baking needs.

Top 7 Popover Pans Review 2020

When reviewing the best popover pans, we looked at multiple features to decide whether a particular model meets the requirements of the majority of home bakers. Some of the features we considered include dimensions, capacity, material, surface, recommended use and warranty. You will find the results of our research in the comparison table below, which is followed by in-depth reviews of each of the models we included. At the end you can also consult our buying guide that has all the information you need so you can choose the perfect popover pan for delicious results.

Editor's Choice

This 2 popover pan set is made from commercial grade silicone, is very easy to use and the food pops out easily even if you don’t use any butter or oil, it is also highly versatile and dishwasher/microwave safe

Read Our Review
10
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Best Value

This model is constructed from aluminized steel that ensures even heating and high heat conductivity, but it is also treated with silicone, which makes it very easy to clean and nonstick at the same time

Read Our Review
9.7
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Budget Pick

This budget-friendly cast-iron popover pan is nonstick and safe to use in all types of ovens and is ideal if you are looking for small cups

Read Our Review
9.5
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Best Nordic Ware Popover Pan

Made of cast aluminum this and with 12 cups this is the ideal choice for those looking for a popover pan that allows them to make bite-size versions of Yorkshire Puddings or muffins

Read Our Review
9.3
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Best 12-Cup Popover Pan

This 12-cup popover pan is made from heavy gauge blast resistant stainless steel, is versatile and dishwasher safe, as well as stain, scratch, and rust resistant

Read Our Review
9.1
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Best for Safety

This 6-cup model, made from 65% recycled steel, has a large border around the edges which allows you to easily hold it safely when removing the pan from the oven

Read Our Review
8.9
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Best Cup Capacity

This 6-cup steel pan has a nonstick coating for easy cleanup and quick release of the food and impressive cup dimensions of 4 x 1.75 inch

Read Our Review
8.7
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each expert independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Features
  • Dimensions: 7.5 x 11 x 2 in, cup – 3 x 2 in
  • Capacity: 6/per pan
  • Best for: large muffins, cupcakes, cheesecake bites, mini pot pies, baked oatmeal, large ice cubes, DIY soap and more
  • Material: silicone
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: FREE extended warranty with registration

 More features: set of 2, built-in stability bars, free recipe eBook, microwave, dishwasher, freezer safe, commercial grade

We chose to feature the Silicone Texas Muffin Pans and Cupcake Maker as our editor’s choice because this popover pan is made from commercial grade silicone that is used by professional kitchens. This means that you will be able to get professional like results in your home kitchen. Moreover, this pan is highly versatile because you can make various types of baking goods in need, including popovers, quiches, pot pies, meatloaf, muffins, and so much more.

Many of the users who tested and reviewed this popover pan in their kitchen mentioned that it is very easy to use and that the food pops out easily even if you don’t use any butter or oil. The Silicone Texas Muffin Pans and Cupcake Maker is dishwasher safe and microwave-safe, and it comes with a recipe book so you can get started with some creative recipes right away.

Pros
  • Professional grade silicone
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Food pops out easily
Cons
  • Bottom could be better
Features
  • Dimensions: 15.5 x 9 x 2.5 in, cup – 2.75 x 2.25 in
  • Capacity: 6
  • Best for: baking muffins, traditional popovers, Yorkshire puddings, cornbread
  • Material: heavy-weight aluminized steel
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: lifetime

 More features: dishwasher safe, oven safe to 450°F / 232°C

Suitable for popovers, Yorkshire puddings and muffins, the Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan comes with six deep wells that are well separated and spaced out so you can obtain excellent results with your baking. The pan is constructed from aluminized steel that ensures even heating and high heat conductivity, but it is also treated with silicone, which makes it very easy to clean and nonstick at the same time.

We liked that the Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan is dishwasher safe for extra easy maintenance, and most of the users who tested it mentioned that it delivers particularly good resides with Yorkshire puddings. The aluminized popover tray is very sturdy and comes with a lifetime warranty for extra peace of mind. The only downside we could find with it is the fact that it only has 6 cups instead of 12.

Pros
  • Made from durable aluminized steel
  • Non-stick silicone treated
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Only has 6 cups
Features
  • Dimensions: 7.62 x 5.25 x 1.5 in, cup – 2.5 x 1.5 in
  • Capacity: 6
  • Best for: mini muffins, cornbread
  • Material: cast iron
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: lifetime

 More features: pre-seasoned, old-fashion style

A heavy-duty popover pan made from cast iron and pre-season so it is ready to use straight out of the box, the Lodge L5P3 Cast Iron Cookware Mini Muffin/Cornbread Pan delivers good results for any kind of popover goods, including Yorkshire puddings and muffins. This cast-iron popover pan is nonstick and safe to use in all types of ovens. This is one of the best choices around if you are looking for a popover pan with small cups. Many users who tested it mentioned that this plan is ideal for those who are looking to cut out on bread consumption and want to bake smaller quantities. The Lodge L5P3 Cast Iron Cookware Mini Muffin/Cornbread Pan comes with a lifetime warranty and has a capacity of six popovers. It is an excellent choice for those who are looking for a quality budget popover pan and if you’re looking for a model that allows you to obtain great results with cornbread.

Pros
  • Sturdy cast-iron design
  • Nonstick surface
  • Lifetime warranty
Cons
  • Very heavy
4.

Nordic Ware Cast Aluminum Petite Popover PanBest Nordic Ware Popover Pan

Features
  • Dimensions: 9 x 14.2 x 1.9 in
  • Capacity: 12
  • Best for: baking, Yorkshire puddings
  • Material: cast aluminum
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: lifetime

 More features: made in the USA

The Nordic Ware Cast Aluminum Petite Popover Pan is the ideal choice for those looking for a popover pan that allows them to make bite-size versions of Yorkshire Puddings or muffins. Made from cast aluminum, this is a non-stick pan and is especially designed to allow maximum airway. This results in popovers that easily reach their full height.

We particularly liked the sturdy feel of this tray and the fact that everything you bake in it pops out easily. With a capacity of 12 cups, the pan is ideal not just for poppers, but also for mini cupcakes and muffins This tray is manufactured by NordicWare, a company that has been producing high-quality baking ware since 1946. The Nordic Ware Cast Aluminum Petite Popover Pan is manufactured in the USA and comes with a lifetime warranty.

Pros
  • Made in the USA
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Durable cast aluminum construction
Cons
  • Heavy
5.

Fox Run 4868Best 12-Cup Popover Pan

Features
  • Dimensions: 10.5 x 13.75 x 1.25 in
  • Capacity: 12
  • Best for: muffins, cupcakes
  • Material: stainless steel
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: 5-year

 More features: dishwasher safe, stain, scratch, and rust resistant surface

One of the best choices around for those who are looking for a 12-cup popover pan, the Fox Run 4868 is made from heavy gauge blast resistant stainless steel. It’s a versatile pan that you can use for making muffins, Yorkshire puddings, and other small baked goods such as cupcakes. We like that this pan is dishwasher safe for easy maintenance and the fact that it is also stain and scratch resistant. It is also an excellent option for those who want to avoid popover pans made from Teflon.

When we tested the Fox Run 4868, we found out that it is very easy to remove the food from it, and we also like that it has a sturdy design and feel that looks like is going to last for the years to come. This popper pan comes with a five-year warranty for extra peace of mind.

Pros
  • Extra durable
  • 12-cup design
  • Non-stick surface
Cons
  • Expensive
6.

USA Pans 6-Well Popover PanBest for Safety

Features
  • Dimensions: 15.75 x 11.25 x 2.43 in, cup – 2.43 x 1.87 in
  • Capacity: 6
  • Best for: popovers
  • Material: aluminized steel
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: lifetime

 More features: commercial grade, FDA approved, made in the USA

Manufactured by an American company based in Pittsburgh, the USA Pans 6-Well Popover Pan is made from 65% recycled steel and has the perfect thickness to maximize air circulation and even heating for efficient baking. This popover pan features a special food grade silicone coating that makes it nonstick while also being safe for the family’s health.

We like that these popover pan has a large border around the edges so you can easily hold it safely when you remove it from the oven, something that is rather difficult to find in other of the models we reviewed. The USA Pans 6-Well Popover Pan can be used at temperatures below 400°F but it is not dishwasher safe. However, we have seen a lot of reviews that mention their pan is durable and rust resistant, and doesn’t require any particular form of maintenance besides simply washing it by hand.

Pros
  • Nonstick surface
  • Thick border around the edges
  • Great air circulation
Cons
  • Not dishwasher safe
7.

Wilton Giant Cupcake PanBest Cup Capacity

Features
  • Dimensions: 8.75 x 13.5 x 2 in, cup – 4 x 1.75 in
  • Capacity: 6
  • Best for: cupcakes, muffins, angel food cakes, to mold gelatin, ice cream or mousse
  • Material: steel
  • Surface: non-stick
  • Warranty: 5-year

 More features: dishwasher safe, 12 oz cup capacity

There are moments when only a jumbo muffin would do, and the Wilton Giant Cupcake Pan is the perfect addition to your kitchen if you want to enjoy bigger and better baked goods. Suitable for cupcakes, muffins, and other types of popover food, this pan is made of steel and it has a nonstick coating for easy cleanup and quick release of the food. We particularly liked the sturdy design of these popover pan and you are likely to be surprised by how large each of the cups in the pan is. Many of the users who reviewed this popover pan mentioned that it is very heavyweight but also that it makes everything very evenly and that it is very easy to take out the food in perfect condition after baking. The Wilton Giant Cupcake Pan comes with a five-year warranty and is dishwasher safe, even though the manufacturer recommends washing it by hand whenever possible.

Pros
  • Large cups
  • Heavy duty design
  • Non-stick coating
Cons
  • Heavyweight

Buying Guide

Popover pans are versatile pieces of bakeware, and choosing the ideal model for your kitchen depends on the type of baking you intend to do, as well as the number of items you want to bake. From material and capacity to ease of cleaning and warranty, there are lots of things to consider when shopping for a popover pan and this guide can help you make an informed decision.

What is a popover pan and what is it used for?

Popover pans are similar to muffin pans, but their intended purpose is to make popover rolls or Yorkshire puddings. Because this type of baking requires the heat to circulate around the sides, popover pans are deeper than regular muffin pans to help the batter “pop” while maintaining a hollow center.

Features to consider while buying the best popover pans

When choosing a popover pan, you should consider multiple things, but first you need to ask yourself what kind of items you want to bake and for how many people you cook. Some of the most important features to think about are dimensions, capacity, material, surface, warranty, and your budget.

Dimensions

The dimensions of a popover pan vary according to the number of cups it has, with 6-cup models being more compact than 12-cup ones. Some models, such as the USA Pans 6-Well Popover Pan, have thick edges so you can handle the pan comfortably when taking it out of the oven, and as such they are larger than other models, even though they are 6-cup models.

Capacity and best uses

The majority of the popover pans available on the market allow you to bake up to 6 or 12 popovers at the same time.

You should choose the best capacity according to the size of your family.
 As for uses, most of the models we tested, including our editor’s choice, the Silicone Texas Muffin Pans and Cupcake Maker, are highly versatile, which means that you can use them for popovers, but also for things such as large muffins, cupcakes, mini pot pies, cheesecake bites, baked oatmeal, and even large ice cubes.

Material and surface

7 Best Popover Pans - Baking Without Frustration

Popover pans are available in multiple materials, ranging from commercial-grade silicone, like the Silicone Texas Muffin Pans and Cupcake Maker, cast iron like the Lodge L5P3 Cast Iron Cookware Mini Muffin/Cornbread Pan, or cast aluminum like the Nordic Ware Cast Aluminum Petite Popover Pan. All these pans have a non-stick surface, but for materials like cast iron you may need to season them from time to time if you want them to maintain their non-stick properties.

Warranty

Popover pans are generally durable items, and most manufacturers offer at least three years of warranty for them. Some models, such as the Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan or the Lodge L5P3 Cast Iron Cookware Mini Muffin/Cornbread Pan come with a lifetime warranty.

Price

The price of a popover pan depends on the material it is made from as well as the manufacturer and size. You can buy a basic model for as little as $10, but be prepared to pay upwards of $30 for a high-quality pan.

FAQ

Most of the popover pans we included in our review are nonstick, which means that you don’t need to use a liner in them. Many recipes call for the use of cooking spray or a bit of oil before adding the batter, but this is not a necessary step if the popover pan is a nonstick one. For models made from cast iron, you need to make sure the pan is pre-seasoned because otherwise it won’t be non-stick.

If you think that the popover pan vs. muffin pan is just a gimmick, you’re wrong. While it might not seem that way at first glance, the truth is that the popover pan gives you a more defined “mushroom top,” which is something that is not as easily attainable with a regular muffin tray. Some of the models we included in our guide and reviews are versatile enough to suit both popovers and muffing, but it’s always a good idea to get a pan that’s specifically designed for popovers it that’s what you intend to bake.

Our Verdict

After reviewing a couple dozens of models available on the market, we made a list of the best popover pans and concluded that the Silicone Texas Muffin Pans and Cupcake Maker is the best choice out there. This versatile pan is made from professional grade silicone and offers commercial-grade results, while also being dishwasher safe and easy to use. Those looking for metallic popover pan that offers great value for money may be interested in the Chicago Metallic Professional 6-Cup Popover Pan, which comes with six deep wells that are spaced out for perfect results every time. Finally, the Lodge L5P3 Cast Iron Cookware Mini Muffin/Cornbread Pan came in third place and is an ideal choice for bakers on a budget or those who want a cast iron popover pan. No matter which model you decide to go for, make sure you care for your popover pan correctly so you can enjoy many years of use.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest