8 Wonderful Pizza Stones for Perfectly Cooked Dough

  • Last updatedLast updated: May 08, 2020
View Article Statistics

Pizza stones come in such a myriad of types and sizes that choosing the right one can be a little tricky. But it doesn’t have to be. We’re here to help you find the absolute best pizza stone for you, whether you want a small stone that can make enough pizza for one or two people, or want a much larger stone for family-size pizzas.

We’ve reviewed 44 products, evaluating what makes them work and identifying which among them offered the most benefits to the consumer. Out of the pizza stones we’ve tried out, the Kamado Joe BJ-PS24 outperformed the rest, earning its place as our Editor’s Choice. A solid stone made from high-impact material, it withstands pressure and high temperature well, and is big enough for larger sizes of pizza. Read more on this and other stones in our Product Reviews section.

Top 8 Pizza Stones Review 2020

To come up with our results, we considered factors like the material, diameter and thickness, oven or grill type, and ease of use. All these affect the pizza stone in different ways and influence how well it works. In the Buying Guide section, we look at these features in greater detail. We explain why you should pay attention to them when choosing a pizza stone for purchase and what to look for when analyzing each feature. We’ve laid out all this information in an easy-to-read format that includes a table, in-detail reviews of each product, a buying guide, tips on using pizza stones, and FAQs.

Editor’s Choice

Ceramic pizza stone that can be used with grill and oven, it fits for pizzas up to 20 inches in diameter

Read Our Review
9.9
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Premium Pick

Square-shaped pizza stone with built-in thermometer, stainless steel base and 15-inch sides

Read Our Review
9.8
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
Best Value

Pizza stone made of cordierite, it fits for most grills and is a very affordable piece

Read Our Review
9.6
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.

Round pizza stone with 16-inch diameter, it can be used in ovens and grills, has a no-spill stopper

Read Our Review
9.5
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.

Cordierite 2-inch thick pizza stone with moisture absorbing carry rack and convenient handles

Read Our Review
9.3
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.

Square pizza stone made of thermion, it withstands 900 degree Fahrenheit heat and can be used with grills and in ovens

Read Our Review
9.2
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.

Ceramic 15-inch pizza stone with stopper handles, it is lightweight and 0.8 inches thick

Read Our Review
9.0
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.

Volcano pizza stone that can be used on a stovetop, it is 0.8 inches thick

Read Our Review
8.9
CookScoreTM
?
CookScore is a ranking system developed by our team of experts. It aggregates all the scores given to a product in various aspects including the individual product’s features evaluation given by each experts independently, its customers’ feedback rank, and sales rank.
1.

Kamado Joe BJ-PS24Editor’s Choice

Features
  • Material: ceramic stone
  • Diameter: 20 in
  • Thickness: 0.75 in
  • Type: grill and oven

More features: needs heat deflector for grilling, high impact materials

The Kamado Joe BJ-PS24 has a diameter of 20 inches and is 0.75 inches thick. Its thicker form, along with the fact that it’s made from high-impact ceramic, make it strong and durable. You may use this pizza stone with a Kamado-type cooker or with the standard oven; it works great with either and is the best pizza stone for oven at its price point. For an enjoyable user experience and best results, your grill should be 2-3″ bigger than the stone. The stone is designed to lie flat, and you won’t need to fit it into any grooves. It’s a simple concept that is meant to help you make pizza with as little fuss as possible. You must first put heat deflectors on the grill, however, before placing the stone to keep your pizza from burning. Add spacers to create some distance between the deflectors and pizza stone to further ensure the bottom of your pizza doesn’t get scorched or stick to the stone. For best results, place the pizza stone as high above the heat deflectors as possible.

The stone comes ready to use and does not need to be seasoned in any way. Simply get your oven ready, place the heat deflectors, put appropriate spacers (like metal sockets, for instance. You can get appropriate spacers from your local hardware store) place the stone, preheat, and when ready, place your pizza and let it cook till ready.

Pros
  • Large
  • High impact ceramic
  • Durable
  • No seasoning
  • Easy to use
Cons
  • Must use with heat deflectors
  • Doesn't come with spacers
2.

Bull 24125 PizzaQuePremium Pick

Features
  • Material: ceramic
  • Diameter: 15 in
  • Thickness: 0.8 in
  • Type: grill and oven

More features: stainless steel set base, built-in thermometer, thermal shock resistant stone

The Bull 24125 PizzaQue square pizza stone is sturdily built from ceramic and should serve you well over the years. The square stone measures 15″ x 15″ x 0.8″. This makes it large enough to make a large pizza and sturdy enough to consistently withstand high temperature, even when you use the stone regularly. The stone is not only strong, but also thermal shock resistant, and will retain its shape and form when you lift it from the oven.

It comes with a stainless steel base, thus eliminating the need to use a heat diffuser. The stainless steel absorbs the extra heat from the oven, allowing the stone to carry only the right amount of heat. This eliminates the likelihood of burning and ensures the pizza cooks evenly.

The best pizza stone for grill, it also comes with a built-in thermometer that will help you monitor heat level as you preheat the stone and when cooking. With this all-in-one package, you don’t need to buy a separate thermometer.

You can also use it with a regular oven. Just ensure that your oven is big enough for the stone to fit inside, which shouldn’t be a problem if you have a standard oven.

The one thing you’ll have to contend with is the weight. This is by no means a light product. It weighs a hefty 18.5 lbs., and certainly requires muscle to lift on and off the oven.

Pros
  • Large
  • Strong ceramic build
  • Stainless steel base
  • Built-in thermometer
  • Thermal shock resistance
Cons
  • Heavy
  • Expensive
Features
  • Material: cordierite
  • Diameter: 12.5 in
  • Thickness: 0.75 in
  • Type: grill

More features: withstands 1200° F, moisture absorbing

The Char-Griller 6211 Smokin’ Stone Jr pizza stone has a diameter of 12.5 inches and is 0.75 inches thick. It is designed for use with the Char-Griller Akorn Jr. Kamado grill and fits the built-in tabs of the grill perfectly.

The stone acts as both a heat deflector and warming stone. It works by keeping the flames away from your food and circulating air around the food so that the food is exposed to just the right amount of heat and the heat evenly distributed. The result is well-cooked food that has all its flavors intact.

The stone is made from cordierite ceramic, a hardy material known for its impressive heat retention, thermal shock resistance, and moisture absorption during cooking. By retaining heat uniformly and consistently, it ensures that your pizza is well-cooked all around. You can also preheat your oven to the higher temperatures suitable for cooking pizza without worrying that the stone will get damaged because the stone can withstand up to 1200 °F. Good thermal shock resistance means you can take the stone from the oven and onto a cooler surface without causing any structural damage.

This is a multi-functional stone that you can use as a slow cooker for your meats. You can also use it to bake things like bread and cookies, not just pizza.

Pros
  • Sturdy cordierite
  • Multi-functional
  • Thermal shock resistant
  • Moisture absorbing
  • Preheats up to 1200 °F
  • Affordably priced
Cons
  • Designed for use with the Akorn Jr. Kamado Grill
  • Not for oven use
Features
  • Material: cordierite
  • Diameter: 16 in
  • Thickness: 0.9 in
  • Type: grill and oven

More features: withstands 1500° F, FDA approved, no-spill stopper, 60-day money back

The FDA-approved Love This Kitchen the Ultimate Pizza Stone for Oven & Grill is designed to bring restaurant-style pizza right into your home and is the best pizza stone for home oven you can get for less than $50. With a thickness of 0.83 inches and a diameter of 16 inches, this stone is big enough for a large pizza that caters for the whole family.

It’s made from cordierite, a type of magnesium aluminum silicate-based ceramic that is strong and durable. The stone absorbs moisture well, enhancing the formation of a tasty, crispy crust and ensuring the pizza doesn’t become soggy inside. Cordierite is also thermal shock resistant, and this means this stone will not get damaged if it’s exposed to a rapid change in temperature.

The No-Spill Stopper at the rear acts as a lift handle and prevents your toppings from spilling over so you can serve a perfect-looking pizza. To guarantee best cooking results, Love This Kitchen uses unique Core Convection Technology to concentrate the heat in the core of the stone and project it outwards for an evenly-cooked product. The stone has excellent heat retention, which means your pizza (and any other baked products you choose to bake using the stone) cook in a shorter time. It also means you can cook multiple pizzas consecutively without waiting for the stone to heat up since it remains hot all through.

Pros
  • Strong cordierite material
  • Thick
  • Moisture absorbing
  • Preheats up to 1500 °F
  • No-spill stopper
  • 100% satisfaction and 30-day money-back guarantee
Cons
  • Heavy
Features
  • Material: cordierite
  • Diameter: 16 in
  • Thickness: 2 in
  • Type: grill

More features: moisture absorbing, carry rack, 2-year limited warranty

The Weber 8836 Gourmet is a popular Weber pizza stone, a fact that has a lot to do with its big, round design and super light weight. It comes with a stainless steel carry rack that makes it a delight to use. And with dimensions of 12 inches across (and 16 inches with the handles), it is the ideal tool for making medium size pizzas. If you have a smaller oven, you may consider using the stone without the rack since it’s removable, and then use heavy oven mitts to remove the stone from the grill.

With the rack in place, you do not need a heat diffuser. Just place the rack directly on top of the grill (on the lip of the hole if using a Weber BBQ grill). It’s this ease of use and compatibility with the grill that makes it the best pizza stone for gas grill all around.

It’s made from cordierite, a strong material with moisture-absorbing properties to help keep the crust of your pizza crisp and flavorful. Because cordierite is resistant to thermal shock, you can place the stone on a preheated oven or transfer it from the grill to a cooler surface without damaging the stone.

The only disappointing thing about it is that it comes with few instructions, so you’ll experiment a bit to see how best to use it with different grills and ovens.

Pros
  • Durable cordierite build
  • Thick
  • Includes carry handles
  • Moisture-absorbing
  • Thermal shock resistant
Cons
  • Scanty user instructions
Features
  • Material: thermion
  • Dimensions: 20 x 13.5 in
  • Thickness: 0.7 in
  • Type: grill and oven

More features: FDA-approved, withstands 900° F, hand-washed

The rectangular Pizzacraft PC9899 pizza stone measures 20″ x 13.5″ x 0.67″ thick, dimensions that make it suitable for use with standard ovens. Pre-2015 versions of this model had a length of 22″, but the stones that are currently on sale (new) are all 20″ long for compatibility with the average oven. It is made from Pizzacraft’s patented thermion material, ThermaBond, an all-natural, thermal shock resistant material that is FDA-approved for safety.

You can use this stone on both the oven and grill. If using the stone in an oven, place it on the bottom rack. For first use, preheat the empty oven for 30 minutes before, then place the stone inside to preheat. If using a grill, place the stone in the middle of the grill. In both cookers, you’ll need to preheat the stone for 30 minutes before placing your pizza or other baked food. Be sure to sprinkle a generous amount of corn flour on the stone before placing the pizza to keep the dough from sticking on to the stone.

The manufacturer recommends storing this stone in the oven when not in use since there is sufficient air circulation in there. Completely air dry the stone before storing it to prevent molding.

What you may not like about this Pizzacraft pizza stone is its weight. At 10.9 lb, it’s quite heavy and will require a good amount of muscle power to lift and move around.

Pros
  • Big size
  • All-natural thermion material
  • FDA-approved
  • Easy to use
  • Easy storage
Cons
  • Heavy
Features
  • Material: ceramic
  • Diameter: 14.75 in
  • Thickness: 0.8 in
  • Type: grill and oven

More features: hand washed, stopper-handles

The PIT BOSS 70137 pizza grill is versatile enough for use in ovens, barbecue grills, ceramic charcoal grills, and wood pellet grills, which makes it great for outdoor and indoor use. It’s the kind of handy gadget that you can take with you when going camping just so no one has to miss their favorite pizza and baked goodies. The stone works by distributing heat evenly to produce a uniformly-cooked pizza with a crispy crust.

This ceramic pizza stone is hard-wearing, and with good care, will last for years. It has a diameter of 14.5 inches and a thickness of 0.8 inches, making it perfect for medium and large pizzas. It weighs only 4.98 lbs. and is light enough for you to lift and carry without straining. Two wooden stopper handles enable you to put the stone in and out of the oven and carry it with ease, while also keeping your toppings from spilling over.

It comes ready to use and requires little maintenance; hand wash with plain water and use a scraper to remove any food residues. That’s it. Use parchment paper between the stone and your dough (or sprinkle cornmeal) to prevent sticking. This will also make cleaning the stone easy.

This stone is also one of the more affordably priced pizza stones. In buying it, you’re not only getting a quality product, but at a great price too.

Pros
  • Light
  • Strong ceramic material
  • Wooden stoppers and handles
  • Can be used on all types of ovens and grills
  • Fairly priced
  • Hand washable
Cons
  • No deal breakers on this one
Features
  • Material: volcano stone
  • Dimensions: 12 x 8 in
  • Thickness: 0.8 in
  • Type: grill

More features: fit for stove top

A multifunctional cooking stone, the rectangular Vital VGL1000-01 Volcano Stone Cooking Tile transforms into a reliable pizza stone whenever you need some homemade pizza. Made from 100% volcano stone, this is an all-natural product that is safe to use in the kitchen, and especially when in direct contact with food. The stone measures 12″ x 8″ x 0.8″, a size that is perfect for small pizzas. Its thick form contributes to its hardiness and durability and considered alongside the stone’s strong and hard-wearing nature, should remain in use for a long time.

The Vital pizza stone is best for use in a grill. It absorbs heat quickly and works by distributing heat uniformly across the stone. The result is an evenly-made pizza and a well-done crust. Volcanic stone has excellent heat diffusion properties and effectively disperses the heat from the grill, ensuring that the dough you’re baking on the stone is exposed to just the right amount of heat. As such, there is no possibility that the crust would burn or get charred, even when you’ve set the temperature at 500 °F or higher. You do not need a heat deflector when using this stone. As noted, it does a great job regulating the heat.

This tile is more than just a pizza stone. You can use it to sear your BBQs, for high temperature plancha-style grilling, and stove top cooking.

Pros
  • 100% natural volcano material
  • Heat diffuser
  • Distributes heat evenly
  • Multifunctional
Cons
  • Small

Buying Guide

From the above product reviews, you can identify which stones are more suitable for your cooking needs, going by the materials used, size, design, supported oven or grill type, and more. In this next section, we address each of these factors in more detail so you can understand what role they play in making the stone useable. We also have tips on the best ways to use a pizza stone and answers to some of the FAQs about pizza stones.

Why you should get a pizza stone

8 Wonderful Pizza Stones for Perfectly Cooked Dough

A pizza stone makes it possible for you to cook and enjoy delicious, pizzeria-style pizza right at home. Forget ordering in whenever you crave pizza; with this stone, you can make your own in less than an hour.

Pizza stones are designed to be used in the oven or grill, and this makes them perfect for home use. Some can only be used with either the oven or grill, but a good number can be used with both, giving you greater flexibility.

They are easy to use. Pizza stones come ready to use. They require no installation, no assembly, and no seasoning.

They are low maintenance. Some can self-clean in the oven, but most only need to be wiped with plain water.

How to use a pizza stone – helpful tips

Place your pizza stone on the lowest rack inside the (cold) oven.
Preheat the oven to 450 °F.
Sprinkle cornmeal on the pizza paddle.
Put the dough on the pizza paddle and add your pizza sauce and toppings.
Slide the pizza onto the pizza stone.
Let it cook for 10 minutes.
Slide the pizza back onto the paddle to remove from the oven.
Serve and enjoy.

Don’ts:
Don’t add the pizza dough to the pizza stone without a barrier like cornmeal or parchment paper between them or the dough will stick to the stone.
Don’t slice your pizza on the pizza stone. This will damage your knife. Instead, transfer the pizza onto a different surface and slice it from there.

Price ranges

Pizza stones are largely affordable, with prices beginning at approximately $30 and going up to $80 for higher end models. Higher cost is not indicative of better quality, however, so you shouldn’t peg your choice of a particular stone on price alone. You’ll find pizza stones with desirable qualities, such as thermal shock resistance, high moisture absorbance, and dual usability, across the price spectrum.

You will find the best pizza stone by the following features

Let’s now look at the specific features to consider when buying a pizza stone.

Material matters

The material of your pizza stone has a lot to do with the quality of pizza you end up with. Because pizza should be cooked at high temperature, the stone should have a higher temperature tolerance than the average cooking pan. At the very least, the material should withstand 500 °F, which is not a problem when it comes to stone. This constant exposure to high temperatures means the stone should also be too hardy to break under the pressure.

Popular materials used to make pizza stones are stone/clay, ceramic, and cordierite. Their tolerance to high temperature varies, though, with cordierite being able to withstand the highest temperature levels. It’s followed by clay, then ceramic. Special types of ceramic, such as cordierite, can withstand up to 1500 °F. You can preheat Char-Griller 6211 Smokin’ Stone Jr up to 1200 °F and the Love This Kitchen the Ultimate Pizza Stone for Oven & Grill up to 1500 °F.

Other qualities to consider when choosing a pizza stone are how quickly the material heats up, and how well it retains heat and absorbs moisture. Out of the three common materials, clay heats up the fastest, while ceramic heats up slowly. Stone and clay have the highest moisture absorbing properties and the strongest heat retention ability, with ceramic following closely.

Cordierite is similar to the others in many ways, and while more expensive, it’s more durable and thermal shock resistant.

Choose the shape

8 Wonderful Pizza Stones for Perfectly Cooked Dough

Pizza stones come in different shapes, the most common being round, square, and rectangle. Some, like Char-Griller 6211 Smokin’ Stone Jr, have extensions that make it round, but not quite. When using a pizza stone, you can shape your dough to follow the shape of the stone, but you don’t have to. Your dough can be in any shape you like, as long as it fits on the stone.

However, if you’re serious about preparing your pizza in a specific, well-defined shape, then it’s advisable to choose a stone that’s made in your desired shape. If you’ll be baking different pastries, not just pizza, a rectangular stone is better suited for that.

Thickness

When choosing between any two stones, always go for the thicker one. The thicker the pizza stone, the better it is going to hold onto the heat, therefore allowing your pizza to cook to perfection. Get one that’s at least ¾-1 inch thick, or if available, pick a stone that is thicker. The ultra thick Weber 8836 Gourmet has a thickness of 2 inches.

Temperatures

The lowest recommended temperature for cooking pizza is 450 °F. You can get better results when you heat the stone to an even higher temperature. Most pizza stones, both ceramic and steel, can safely be preheated to more than 1200 °F. So check what the maximum temperature is before buying the stone. The higher the temperature limit, the more you can do with the stone.

Size

There are pizza stones of all sizes in the market. Where possible, choose the biggest size you can afford because the bigger the stone, the greater the variety of pizza sizes and shapes you can cook.

It’s also crucial to ensure that the size of stone you pick can fit in your oven or grill. The maximum size that can fit a standard oven is 20 inches. Fortunately, many pizza stones are designed to fit in the average oven and will hardly be bigger than 20″. If you have a smaller oven, choose a smaller stone to avoid wasting money on a stone that won’t fit in the oven.

Surface

The surface of the stone entails the area onto which you place the pizza for baking. If the surface is small, you can only cook small pizzas on it. A larger surface allows you to bake large pizzas. When evaluating the surface area of your pizza stone, do not include the carry handles, if any. Consider the flat part only.

Guarantees

Opt for a stone that comes with a warranty. Some of the lower-priced pizza stones do not have warranties, but a good number come with comprehensive guarantees from the manufacturer. The Weber 8836 Gourmet, for example, comes with a 2-year warranty. Love This Kitchen The Ultimate Pizza Stone for Oven & Grill has 100% satisfaction guarantee backed by a 60-day money-back policy and a limited lifetime guarantee.

Oven or grill use

Is the pizza stone designed for the oven, grill, or both? If you prefer to bake your pizza on the grill, choose a stone that is designed for the grill, and vice versa for the oven. A pizza stone that can be used on both types of cookers offers greater flexibility, such that if you’re cooking something else on one cooker, you can bake your pizza on the other.

How easy is it to clean?

Overall, pizza stones are easy to clean. Make it a habit to clean the stone after every use, but only after it has cooled down. Handling the stone while it’s hot will burn you.

If there are charred bits of dough on the stone, use a scraper to lightly remove them. Avoid the temptation to use a sharp object to remove food remains as this could damage the stone.

8 Wonderful Pizza Stones for Perfectly Cooked Dough

Then wipe using plain warm water to rinse. You don’t want the stone to absorb a huge amount of water because when it does and you don’t dry it properly, the next time you use it, it will steam the crust and won’t yield that crispy pizza texture we all love. That means you shouldn’t soak the stone in water either. If for some reason the stone ends up absorbing water, place it in the oven and heat it up to get rid of the water. Allow it to cool and then store it.

If there are stubborn food remains that won’t come off after you’ve tried scraping them off, put the stone in the oven and preheat for a couple of hours at 500 °F. The remains should now come off easily.

FAQ

While a steel pizza stone heats up fast, it also loses heat quickly, meaning you have to closely monitor the pizza while it cooks and may need to adjust your baking settings appropriately to get the best results. A pizza stone produces better results because it heats up evenly and retains heat well, allowing the pizza to cook fully and in a uniform manner.

It is better to cook in a pizza stone. Here’s why: The stone heats up uniformly, ultimately producing an evenly-cooked pizza. It also draws out moisture from the dough, ensuring that you don’t end up with soggy pizza. Because it has a higher amount of initial heat, the stone produces a puffed up crust, which you won’t get with a pan.

Simply wipe with a wet cloth (don’t use soap or other detergent) to get rid of any dirt from the factory and allow it to dry completely. Preheat the stone as instructed by the manufacturer. Your stone is ready for use.

No. Most pizza stones come ready to use and don’t require seasoning. The only thing you should do is sprinkle cornmeal, semolina, or breadcrumbs to prevent sticking. Applying a thin layer of oil as you would a cast iron pan will result to smoking when you turn up the heat, which isn’t how you want to cook your pizza.

Our Verdict

Our top choice, the Kamado Joe BJ-PS24, earns the first place for its big size and quality ceramic construction. We like the high-impact materials and thickness, qualities that make it so strong that it doesn’t break easily. We also like that you can use it with both the oven and grill.

The second position goes to the Bull 24125 PizzaQue, a ceramic creation that is designed for both the oven and grill. We like how thick and sturdy it is, and its high thermal shock resistance. We also like that it comes with a steel base and a built-in thermometer.

Our third best pizza stone is the Char-Griller 6211 Smokin’ Stone Jr, a small cordierite stone that is designed for the grill and one that fits perfectly into the Akorn Jr. Kamado. We like how sturdy it is, how well it absorbs moisture, that it can withstand temperatures of up to 1200 °F, and that it’s affordably priced.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest