Judith is a fairy in the world of writing: she manages to turn any topic (far not only a kitchen-related) into an entertaining text that is so easy and educating to read. Fond of gardening, reading, and cooking, of course.
Emily has over 10 years of professional experience using, testing and comparing kitchen appliances. Her knowledge helps to easily and naturally solve everyday problems. She is also the owner of the lifestyle blog emilyreviews.com
Last updated: July 18, 2021
Did you know that the pizza peel you use can heavily influence the outcome of your pizza? Since this is the case, purchasing one of the best pizza peels in the market is in your best interests. Once you do, you can eliminate the peel as the possible reason why your pizza outcomes aren’t the best.
As a team, we reviewed a couple of excellent options. The main features we used to grade different products were weight, handle length, and blade size. In addition to other factors, the size of your pizza peel will influence how big you can make your pizzas. Also, the weight and handle length are likely to dictate how you handle the peel. Additionally, the material makeup of the peel will tell you how long you can expect the tool to last as well as whether it can be used for any other functions. Once you are familiar with these features, you can go about finding the best pizza peel options, as we have done below.
Despite being technically made of grass, bamboo options give the best wooden pizza peels a run for their money. One might even consider this Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Pizza Peel superior to wooden options. However, this is purely based on merit, where a few factors, including the construction, have been considered.
One thing the manufacturer is vocal about is the versatility of the tool. After all, it does look and feel like a chopping board and can be used as such. Also, there is no rule against using it to remove bread from the oven.
Additionally, there is a claim by the manufacturer that the tool does not crack, warp, or splinter. Since this is the case, your hands should be safe when handling the device.
Speaking of handling, one might even take note of the easy-grip handle. Consequently, people of all ages and sizes will have quite an easy time using it to remove their pizzas from the oven. Also, the weight is part of the reason why the device is easy to handle.
You as well shouldn’t have a hard time cleaning the tool. Hand washing with a bit of warm water is recommended. Another significant benefit is the 180-day guarantee. As such, make sure to use the tool soon after it arrives so that you can decide whether to keep it or not.
Why is it special?
Relatively easy to clean
Easy-grip handle for more comfortable handling
What are the flaws?
Some users have complained about the edges being too thick
Also, its size doesn’t allow for use with larger pizzas
The next peel on our list is the SHANGPEIXUAN Perforated Pizza Peel. As you can see, this tool features unique construction alongside a different design to that of the editor’s choice. Nevertheless, performance should be close to or on par with its predecessor.
One of the things users of the previous tool complained about was the thickness. This is something they are guaranteed not to worry about if they choose this option instead. Nevertheless, the pizza surface is more or less the same size.
A disparity occurs in the size of the handle. As it stands, the overall length of the tool is 47 inches. If you feel the need to be further away from your oven as you are putting in your pizza, this tool is the way to go.
Also noteworthy is the hard-film anodized aluminum body and construction of the tool. Durability and heat resistance is thus guaranteed.
The perforated design is also quite innovative. It will allow the flour under the dough to find an exit, and as such, you won’t have to deal with a burnt crust.
Other features you might appreciate are a flexible head and a tubular design of the handle. The former will allow you to achieve a scraper effect, which makes loading of the dough onto the peel a cinch. As for the latter, it makes the tool lightweight and more balanced for easier handling.
What makes it special?
Reduces the likelihood of burnt crust by providing an exit for flour under the dough
Durable and heat resistant
What cons did we find?
You need to purchase gloves as a precaution since the peel gets hot quickly
The Fiery Chef Bamboo Pizza Peel does make portioning the pizza a walk in the park. This is because it includes grooves in the design. As such, you should get some equal portions to distribute to the whole family.
Also, this is one of a few tools made of bamboo on the list. If you have already seen one, you can expect a few similar features. One major one is that it doesn’t splinter when used. You will thus be able to use the tool without fear of injury.
Also, it is a multipurpose device, meaning you can use it for more than just pizza. The double-sided design should help with that since one side does not come with grooves.
Another benefit is the inclusion of tapered edges. These make it easy to slide the product under the pizza when it is ready and pull out the finished product. Also, the fact that it comes with a guarantee is something buyers should be happy about.
What stands out?
Easy to use
Storage is easy owing to the hole in the handle
What cons did we manage to find?
The handle seems too short for some
The product is also a little too thick for some people’s liking.
Another bamboo pizza peel makes it onto our list as well. This time it is the Frederica Trading Bamboo Wooden Pizza Peel Paddle. It is undoubtedly a large option when it comes to peel surface since it measures 13.5” x 13.5”.
The overall length of the product, including the handle, is just a little bit longer. Given its bamboo body, there will be little need to use gloves. However, you could still get them as a precaution since you will be dealing with flames and ovens.
Also, the weightlessness is impressive, given that this is a relatively large tool. Like the editor’s choice, this option could also serve multiple purposes. Top on the list of use scenarios is as a chopping block.
Additionally, no one can claim the durability of the tool to be lacking. As such, it does represent a smart investment on your part. The manufacturer also wants you to know that it is certified safe and non-toxic.
Why is it special?
Versatile and multipurpose
Easy to use
What are the flaws?
The fact that it is thick means getting under the pizza is not very easy
The Camp Chef Pizza Accessories Kit, as the name suggests, comes with multiple products in the same purchase. As such, the current pricing is not so bad considering the value you get. With this, you have almost everything you need to start making pizzas. That is except for the ingredients, oven, and maybe a pizza stone.
It ships with two peels. As such, you can use one until it is old and damaged before throwing it out and using the other one. For a commercial setting with two or more ovens, you might also get to use the peels simultaneously.
Each of the peels is 11” x 12” with a rather small handle. As such, some people may be less willing to buy it. Nevertheless, the fact that it is wooden means it won’t transfer heat as much as other options. Consequently, your hands should be relatively safe.
Additionally, the presence of a pizza cutter and a spatula cannot be downplayed. Both of these accessories can be quite useful in the pizza-making and serving process.
What do we love it for?
Relatively lightweight pizza peels
Wooden construction does not conduct heat
What were we disappointed with?
The small size of the peels may not be everybody’s cup of tea
There seem to be some issues with the packaging which sometimes leads to damage of the products
If you are just getting into pizza making, you could shave off some of the overall cost by buying this product instead. This is because you get three products in the same package. You would typically have to buy them individually at a higher cost.
The most crucial component of the package is the pizza peel. After all, it is the reason why you are reading this write-up. It features a 9½” x 10½” blade, which is by most standards relatively small. As such, you shouldn’t choose this option if you are looking to make large pizzas.
It also has an 11½” handle as well. Worth noting is that both the blade and the handle are made of stainless steel. Admittedly the handle is also coated by some insulating material, so you don’t hurt your hands.
Apart from the pizza peel for home use, there is also a pizza stone included. Some pizza experts have recommended this as how to get even heating on your pizza. As such, it does prove quite a valuable accessory. Also, it measures 13” in diameter and is quite thick. This explains why the package weighs a total of 5.7 lbs.
Additionally, the pizza cutter should help a lot when it comes to serving people their slices.
What do we love it for?
Comes with multiple useful accessories
What were we disappointed with?
Some users have noted that the cutter could be of better quality
Users also seem to have difficulty cleaning the pizza stone
The Winco 42-Inch Wooden Pizza Peel is a high-quality product that would fit the needs of anyone looking for a large peel. Given its 18” x 18” blade size, it is understandable that it weighs as much as it does.
However, the total length is about 42”. This should give you enough clearance, so you are well away from the heat in your oven. Also, with all factors considered, it is understandable that it weighs a total of 2.3 lbs. Nevertheless, that is still a lot of weight for users.
Whether you are comfortable with this weight or not will help determine if you can make the purchase. Also, with the edges having a slight slope, it should be relatively easy to slide the tool under a pizza. The only remaining course of action after that is to pull out your pizza and cut it into pieces.
What are its best features?
Offers a large peel surface
Robust and durable
Edges make it easier to slip the tool under a hot pizza
The Komista Turning Pizza Peel for Brick Oven comes with a 47” handle in addition to the 9” blade. As such, it totals 56” in length. This size may appeal to some of you, while to others it may seem like overkill.
Additionally, the construction of the tool is to be noted. The blade, for instance, alongside most of the handle, is made of stainless steel. Durability is likely not something you will have to worry about.
However, the tool incorporates a high-density polymer handle as well. This is also complemented by a sliding grip that makes the turning of the pizza a bit easier.
This tool will even work great for an outdoor wood-fired oven. Also, you shouldn’t have any problems using it in a commercial setting. Additionally, the handle is attached to the peel using three rivets for added stability.
Also noteworthy is the milling around the head of the device. You want something that will easily slide under a pizza, whether from the front or side. This feature will help give you that. As a result, turning the pizza and ensuring even cooking is easier.
The tool also has a perforated surface that should get rid of the flour on the underside of the dough.
What makes it special?
Easy to use
Perforation allows you to get rid of excess flour under the dough
A more affordable metal pizza peel comes in the form of the Chicago Brick Oven Aluminum Turning Pizza Peel. However, it does come with wooden components as well in the handle. This should allow you to handle the tool without using gloves.
You should know that the handle is detachable. This makes cleaning as well as storage a hell of a lot easier. Also, a small leather strap is included. If you want to hang it in your kitchen, this feature should allow you to do so.
When you compare this tool to some of its metal predecessors, you will realize a significant difference in design. The premium pick and Komista Turning Pizza Peel for Brick Oven feature perforated surfaces while this one is rather smooth.
However, the way to prevent sticking of the dough is the same for all the options. It includes coating the surface with flour before positioning the dough on top. There are also other options for achieving the same effect. They include cornmeal or wheat bran.
Also, despite its small size, it can be used to turn even 14” pizzas while they are in the oven. This is made possible by the tapered edge that slides under dough quite easily.
What are its best features?
Easy to use
Easy to store
Easy to clean
The tool does not require gloves due to its insulated handle
A large wooden option may be what you are looking for. In this case, you would do well to consider the Epicurean Pizza Peel for purchase. It has one of the larger peel surfaces on the list hence deserves praise for that.
Also, given its wooden body, it might be worth it to try using it as a chopping board. You can see how well it holds up then decide if you are going to keep using it the same way. You also do know for sure is that it is dishwasher safe. This feature is not in a lot of other products on the list hence deserves commendation.
Additionally, it is temperature resistant to the tune of 350°F. This is necessary since you will be using it with your oven that is likely pre-heated. It should thus hold up very well against those challenging conditions.
For storage, you have a hole near the edge of the handle. It will allow you to hang the tool in the kitchen, waiting for when it next needs to be used. It also ranks well on the weightlessness meter. Additionally, the beveled front edge makes it so much easier to scoop pizzas.
What makes it stand out?
Easy to use
Large peel surface
Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?
Some buyers complain of a pungent smell from the wood pizza peel
Others don’t like the short handle of the product
Things to Consider
You may be reading this write-up in search of a high-quality pizza peel that works for you. If you choose one product randomly out of the ten options above, you may still be disappointed with what you get.It is more cost-effective to learn the things you should look out for in a pizza peel. That way, you will make smart choices. As such, you may benefit from the knowledge in this buying guide below both now and in the future.
Why buy a pizza peel?
There are two main reasons for you to acquire a pizza peel. The first is that the tool will allow you to slide your dough onto a pizza stone in the oven. This is after you have added all the toppings. Remember that you have to pre-heat the stone as preparation for making your pizza. As such, if you make a mistake and touch it, you may suffer severe burns. The pizza peel helps you avoid this.
Second, you want your pizza to cook evenly, and that requires turning it while it is in the oven. A pizza peel will allow you to do this with relative ease. Another benefit of turning pizzas using your peel is that it reduces or eliminates charring.
Features to consider when choosing a pizza peel
Choosing a pizza peel based on merit is the wisest thing to do. As such, you need to learn all there is to learn about the features to expect. Consequently, you can figure out which ones will be of most benefit to you. This will, of course, make choosing the best pizza peel option a piece of cake. This information is provided in the section below.
Bamboo is quite a popular option in the making of pizza peels, as is wood and metal. Each of these will have its benefits. Products like the Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Pizza Peel made of bamboo don’t chip or damage easily. They also don’t conduct heat. Consequently, it may be hard for them to cause you injury.
Also, one cannot forget the fact that some of them can be used as chopping boards. The same is the case for wooden pizza peels. However, options made from these two materials tend to be quite thick. This can be problematic when trying to slide it under the cooked pizza in the oven.
Metal peels don’t seem to have the same problem. They are quite thin and can easily lift and turn pizzas. However, you might need to handle some of them with gloves since touching a hot part will lead to burns. Additionally, they are often lighter in weight than their other counterparts.
These differences make the three options available to you ideal for a variety of situations. As such, you may have to ask yourself a few questions about your pizza-making process before you make a purchase.
Wooden options such as the Epicurean Pizza Peel tend to have a more rectangular shape. The same is the case for bamboo peels. This allows them a much easier time while offloading dough into the oven. However, circular peels seem much better at turning pizzas.
You will need to choose blade size depending on the size of the oven alongside the size of the pizzas you intend to make. Products like the Winco 42-Inch Wooden Pizza Peel with its 18” x 18” blade may not even fit some ovens. However, if you want to make small pizzas, you can pick out a peel with a small blade even if you have a large oven.
A long handle will give you a lot of clearance from the oven. This will make turning pizzas easy without the risk of touching a hot surface. Nonetheless, if all you need to do is take pizzas in and out of the oven, a short handle may be sufficient. Don’t forget that you can buy gloves as an extra protective measure to keep your hands burn-free.
Another thing worth noting is that pizza dough can be weighty. This is true for ready pizzas as well. As such, you don’t want to use a heavy peel that will make it near impossible to remove pizzas from the oven. Of course, this is dependent on your body strength as well.
Looking into extra features is a tradition you should foster in any purchase. An example is how the perforated design of the SHANGPEIXUAN Perforated Pizza Peel eliminates flour from the underside of the dough. This reduces the chances of charring on your pizza.
Another extra feature you can benefit from is the inclusion of grooves in the Fiery Chef Bamboo Pizza Peel. This is a handy feature for when the pizza is ready and needs to be cut into pieces. Likewise, seeing other features in a potential pizza peel purchase should be cause for excitement as it means more value for you.
How to take care of your pizza peel
Taking care of a pizza peel is different for wood and bamboo options as compared to their metal counterparts. The first two need special care where you might need to wipe the product occasionally with mineral oil. This should also be done when you first receive the package.
After that, you can put the peel in soapy water before scrubbing gently. Rinsing is the next step, followed by wiping the peel dry. You as well need to allow all the residual moisture to dissipate before taking the next step. Once this is done, another coat of mineral oil should be applied. Storage is the last step.
Of course, you should season the peel before you use it as well. This entails applying the mineral oil then lining the surface with flour. Metal options only need to be cleaned, rinsed, dried, and stored. They can also benefit from a coat of flour before being used to handle pizza dough.
Wood seems like the go-to option for the preparation of pizzas. However, it does have some downsides such as splintering and being more difficult to maintain. Metal pizza peels are often stickier than their counterparts. Nonetheless, they do have the benefit of easy maintenance. As such, there is no better option. Additionally, the benefits you want from your peel will help determine your purchase choice.
Seasoning a wood pizza peel requires you to apply mineral oil before use. You also need to allow sufficient time for the oil to soak into the peel. Additionally, a coat of cornmeal or floor is required before you place any dough on the device. Always make sure this coat of flour is thin and spread evenly. Remember to brush all materials off the surface once the cooking process is done.
You should oil your pizza peel with mineral oil. However, if you use any other type of oil, it may turn rancid.
Once you are done reading this write-up, you will likely have decided which product you want to buy. If you haven’t, we have a few favorites from the list above. The Pizza Royale Ethically Sourced Premium Pizza Peel is one of them. The 180-day guarantee is one reason why we regard this tool so highly.
Other reasons are that it is durable, safe to use, and can be used for more than just making pizzas. Another tool that we favor is the SHANGPEIXUAN Perforated Pizza Peel. Durable construction and a long handle make a good case for its purchase. The perforated surface can also be quite useful.
The last of our favorite options is the Fiery Chef Bamboo Pizza Peel, with most of the benefits the number one tool has. Additionally, if you can’t seem to cut your pizza slices evenly, this tool is for you since it provides grooves for guidance. If you still haven’t decided what tool to go for, you can reread the above write-up. The second or third time you do may be the charm.